David Burke Kitchen is reader-supported. When you buy through links on our site, we may earn an affiliate commission. Learn more

Cast Iron vs Nonstick

By David Burke

When it comes to cooking, selecting the correct type of pan or skillet is essential for creating a great meal. Whether you’re a professional chef or just starting the kitchen, having the right cookware can make all the difference.

Choosing the right type of cookware is crucial not only for the quality and taste of your meals but also for the longevity of your cooking tools and your overall health. The type of pan you use can greatly impact the cooking process, affecting how evenly the heat distributes over the pan, the amount of sear on your meat, and even how much oil is needed to prevent sticking. Moreover, some materials may have health hazards if not properly used and maintained.

Cast Iron vs Nonstick

There are many options available but two of the most popular approaches are cast iron vs nonstick cookware. Each has its own merits and drawbacks that need to be considered before making an informed decision on which one best suits your cooking needs. In this blog post, we’ll explore some of the advantages and disadvantages that come with each option, helping you to decide whether cast iron or nonstick is best for your kitchen setup.

Overview of Cast Iron Cookware

Cast iron skillets are manufactured through a process that has been refined over centuries. To begin, raw materials, primarily iron, and carbon, are melted together in a furnace. Once the mixture reaches a molten state, it’s poured into a sand mold that’s shaped like the desired skillet. After the iron has cooled and solidified, the mold is broken away, revealing the rough shape of the skillet. The skillet is then machine-finished to smooth out any rough edges and surfaces.

Finally, it is often pre-seasoned, or coated with a layer of oil and baked, creating a natural nonstick surface. This entire process creates a durable piece of cookware that, with proper care, can last for generations.

Key Features and Benefits of Cast Iron Cookware

Cast iron cookware is an incredibly versatile and durable option for cooking enthusiasts and professionals alike. One of the standout features of cast iron cookware is its extreme heat tolerance, making it suitable for use on all cooktops, as well as in the oven. In addition, it is also induction compatible.

But the benefits of cast iron cookware go beyond its heat tolerance. cast iron cookware is also renowned for its excellent heat retention, ensuring that your meals will remain deliciously hot and evenly cooked. Furthermore, its weight, thickness, and even temperature distribution make it perfect for high-heat searing, slow simmering, baking, and roasting.

In addition to its impressive performance, cast iron cookware is also very safe to use. Unlike many non-stick coatings, which can release chemicals into your food and environment, cast iron cookware is entirely chemical-free. Cast iron cookware is also free of any synthetic materials, which means that it won’t warp or scratch.

Another outstanding feature of cast iron cookware is its durability. Unlike other cookware materials, cast iron cookware is incredibly resilient and can last a lifetime, making it an excellent investment. Additionally, cast iron cookware is straightforward to clean and maintain, making it an excellent choice for those who value convenience.

In conclusion, if you’re looking for cookware that can withstand extreme heat, retain heat well, and is versatile, safe, durable, and affordable, cast iron cookware is a great choice. Its countless benefits make it a must-have item in any kitchen.

  • Extreme Heat Tolerance
  • Excellent Heat Retention
  • Versatility
  • Safety
  • Durability
  • Easy to Maintain
Overview of Cast Iron Cookware

Potential Drawbacks

While cast iron cookware boasts durability and versatility, it also presents several potential drawbacks for users. One such drawback is its heavy weight, which can make it difficult to handle and maneuver, especially when filled with hot food. Additionally, cheaper cast iron products may have a rough finish that can lead to food sticking and burning, making it hard to clean and maintain.

Another potential issue with cast iron cookware is that it heats up slowly, which can be frustrating for those who want to cook quickly or efficiently. This is particularly true for larger pieces of cast iron, such as Dutch ovens, which can take a long time to reach their desired temperature. This slow heating process also makes it challenging to make adjustments or corrections to the cooking temperature.

The integrated handles and knobs that are common on cast iron cookware can also pose a problem for users. These elements can become incredibly hot during use, which can be dangerous if someone accidentally touches them or forgets to use an oven mitt. This can be particularly concerning for households with young children or inexperienced cooks.

Furthermore, cast iron cookware requires seasoning before it can be used properly. This means that a layer of oil or fat needs to be applied and baked onto the surface before its first use. This process helps to prevent rust and promotes better food release but can be time-consuming and inconvenient for some users. Failure to season cast iron properly can result in rust, which can ultimately damage the cookware and affect the taste of the food.

Read more: how to use cast iron Skillet first time?

Lastly, sudden temperature changes can cause cast iron cookware to crack, particularly if it has not been adequately seasoned or is exposed to extreme temperature fluctuations. This can be problematic for users who want to use their cast iron cookware in different types of cooking environments, such as on the stovetop and in the oven.

In conclusion, while cast iron cookware is a popular option for many households, it does come with some potential drawbacks that should be considered before purchasing. These include its heaviness, rough finish (if cheap), slow heating, hot handles, and knobs, seasoning requirements, susceptibility to rust, and potential to crack with sudden temperature changes.

  • Heaviness
  • Rough Finish (Lower quality)
  • Slow Heating
  • Hot Handles and Knobs
  • Seasoning Requirements
  • Susceptibility to Rust
  • Potential to Crack with Sudden Temperature Changes

Overview of Nonstick Cookware

Nonstick cookware is manufactured through a process of applying a nonstick coating to a base material, often aluminum. The first step in this process is to shape the aluminum into the required cookware form, typically via a pressing or casting method. Once the cookware shape is achieved, the surface is subjected to a series of treatments to ensure the nonstick coating adheres properly.

These treatments include roughening the surface to improve adhesion and applying a primer coat. After these preparational steps, the nonstick coating is applied. This is often done by spraying multiple layers of the nonstick material onto the surface, which are each cured at high temperatures to create the finished nonstick product.

The nonstick coating itself is typically made from a material like polytetrafluoroethylene (PTFE) or ceramic. The application and curing process ensures that the nonstick coating is securely bonded to the cookware surface, providing the easy-release and easy-cleaning properties nonstick cookware is known for. Despite the complexity of this manufacturing process, nonstick cookware is typically very affordable, making it a popular choice for many home cooks.

Key Features and Benefits of Nonstick Cookware

Nonstick cookware is a popular choice among many home cooks and professional chefs alike due to its wide array of key features and benefits that make cooking easier and more enjoyable. One of the most significant benefits of nonstick cookware is its ease of use. With its slick surface, food slides off effortlessly, making cooking a breeze. This feature not only saves time but also reduces the amount of oil or butter needed to cook, making it a cost-effective solution for many households.

A versatile kitchen tool, nonstick cookware is suitable for a variety of dishes, including pancakes, eggs, and fish fillets. Its versatility also makes it an excellent option for sautéing vegetables and stir-frying meats. Additionally, nonstick cookware is ideal for delicate foods such as fish and pastries, as it prevents them from sticking to the pan and falling apart.

Easy clean-up is another key feature of nonstick cookware. With traditional cookware, burnt-on food and grease can be difficult to remove without the use of harsh cleaning chemicals. However, nonstick cookware is easy to clean, requiring only a quick rinse with soapy water and a gentle scrub of the surface.

Healthier cooking is also a significant advantage of nonstick cookware. As previously mentioned, its non-stick surface reduces the amount of oil or butter required to cook food, making meals healthier and more nutritious. In addition, nonstick cookware is often made of materials that allow for the even distribution of heat without hot spots, further promoting healthy cooking.

In conclusion, nonstick cookware is not only easy to use, versatile, and cost-effective, but it is also an ideal choice for healthier cooking and delicate foods. Its non-stick surface and easy clean-up make it an essential kitchen tool for chefs of all skill levels. Whether you are a professional chef or a home cook, nonstick cookware is an investment that can improve your cooking experience and enhance the quality of your meals.

  • Ease of Use
  • Versatility
  • Easy Clean-up
  • Healthier Cooking
  • Even Heat Distribution
  • Ideal for Delicate Foods
Overview of Nonstick Cookware

Potential Drawbacks

Nonstick cookware is a popular choice for many home cooks due to its convenience and ease of use. However, there are several potential drawbacks that should be considered before purchasing such cookware.

One of the most significant drawbacks of nonstick cookware is its durability. Unlike traditional cookware made from materials such as cast iron or stainless steel, nonstick cookware is not as durable and can become easily scratched or damaged. This is because the nonstick coating is applied to a relatively soft base material, typically aluminum, which can be easily scratched or dented.

Another potential issue with nonstick cookware is that it requires special utensils. Metal utensils, such as spatulas or tongs, can scratch the nonstick coating and damage the pan. Instead, users must use non-metallic utensils, such as silicone or wooden spoons, which can be less durable and may need to be replaced more frequently.

In addition to requiring specific utensils, nonstick cookware also requires specific care. It should not be washed in the dishwasher, as the harsh detergents and high temperatures can damage the nonstick coating. Instead, it should be hand washed with mild soap and water.

Nonstick cookware is also not always oven safe. While some nonstick cookware can withstand high oven temperatures, many cannot. This can limit the types of dishes that can be prepared in nonstick cookware, as well as the cooking techniques that can be used.

Finally, nonstick cookware has a limited lifespan. Over time, the nonstick coating can wear off, exposing the base material and reducing the effectiveness of the pan. This can also raise health concerns as the base material may be exposed to food.

Overall, while nonstick cookware can be a convenient choice for some cooks, there are several potential drawbacks that should be taken into consideration. These include limited durability, the need for specific utensils and care, and the limited lifespan of the nonstick coating.

  • Less Durable
  • Special Utensils Required
  • Specific Care
  • Limited Oven Safety
  • Limited Lifespan

Comparison of Cast Iron vs Nonstick Cookware


When it comes to durability, cast iron cookware outshines nonstick alternatives by an impressive margin. The natural, rugged finish of cast iron pans can withstand higher heat and rougher handling, including the use of metal utensils, without showing signs of wear or damage. The fact that these pans can last for decades, and often become treasured family heirlooms, is a testament to their robustness.

On the other hand, nonstick pans have a fleeting lifespan, with the coating often peeling or flaking off after a few years of use, even with careful handling. The durability of cast iron cookware, therefore, makes it a more sustainable and cost-effective choice in the long run.

Heat Tolerance

The heat tolerance of cookware is a critical consideration for cooking at high temperatures. Cast iron holds the upper hand in this regard. It is capable of withstanding very high heat, making it ideal for searing, browning, and grilling. Moreover, cast iron retains heat exceptionally well, ensuring even cooking and maintaining the temperature even when cold food is added to the pan.

Nonstick cookware, conversely, cannot bear the same level of heat as cast iron. Excessive heat can cause the nonstick coating to deteriorate or release harmful fumes. Therefore, nonstick pans are usually recommended for low to medium-heat cooking. This limitation can be restrictive for certain cooking techniques and recipes that require high heat. Thus, when it comes to heat tolerance, cast iron cookware proves to be significantly superior.

Heat Retention and Distribution

A vital aspect of cooking is the retention and distribution of heat, which greatly influences the outcome of your dish. Cast iron excels in both these areas. Its superior heat retention keeps the food warm for longer, making it an excellent choice for slow-cooking dishes. Additionally, cast iron distributes heat evenly across its surface, reducing the chances of hot spots and ensuring uniform cooking. This is particularly advantageous when making dishes that need consistent heat, like pan roasts or stews.

In contrast, nonstick cookware struggles with both heat retention and distribution. While these pans heat up quickly, they cool down just as swiftly, making them less suitable for dishes that require sustained, even heat. Furthermore, heat distribution in nonstick pans can be uneven, potentially leading to unevenly cooked food. When considering heat retention and distribution, cast iron cookware is undeniably the superior choice.

Ease of Use

When comparing the ease of use, nonstick cookware tends to be more user-friendly, especially for beginners. Its main advantage lies in its nonstick coating, which reduces the amount of oil or fat needed for cooking and makes food release effortlessly from the pan. This feature allows for easy flipping, stirring, and sliding out of food, which can greatly simplify the cooking process.

Ease of Use

Moreover, nonstick cookware is typically lighter in weight, making it easier to handle, especially when cooking large meals or using larger pans. It also tends to heat up quickly, which can reduce cooking times and enhance efficiency in the kitchen.

On the other hand, cast iron cookware can be more challenging to handle due to its significant weight. It also requires pre-seasoning and more detailed care and maintenance to prevent rusting and maintain its nonstick properties. However, once a cast iron pan is well-seasoned, it also offers a good nonstick surface.

In summary, while nonstick pans may offer greater ease of use, particularly for novice cooks, cast iron pans can be equally efficient once you get accustomed to them.

Easy to Clean

In terms of cleanliness, nonstick cookware generally takes the lead. The smooth, nonstick surface of these pans makes cleaning a painless task. Food residues or grime can be easily wiped off with a sponge and mild detergent, restoring the pan to its pristine condition. This feature can save significant time and effort, especially after preparing sticky or burnt food.

Cast iron cookware, however, requires a different cleaning approach. It isn’t advisable to use soap or harsh cleaning supplies, as they can strip the pan’s seasoning. Usually, scrubbing with coarse salt and a non-metal brush, followed by a rinse with warm water, is enough. After cleaning, it’s essential to thoroughly dry the pan to prevent rust, and occasionally re-season it to maintain its nonstick properties. Although this process may sound cumbersome, it becomes rather effortless with practice. Therefore, if ease of cleaning is a priority, nonstick pans may be the more convenient choice, but with proper care, cast iron can also be manageable.

Maintenance and Care

Caring for your cookware properly can significantly extend its lifespan and performance. Cast iron cookware requires a specific maintenance routine to prevent rusting and to maintain its non-stick properties. After each use, clean the pan with warm water and a stiff brush, avoiding harsh detergents. Dry the cookware thoroughly to prevent rusting, and then apply a thin layer of vegetable oil to protect its non-stick surface. Always remember to heat the cookware slowly to avoid thermal shock.

Nonstick cookware, on the other hand, requires less rigorous maintenance. However, it’s essential to use utensils that won’t scratch or chip the non-stick surface, such as wooden or silicone utensils. Although it’s dishwasher safe, hand washing is recommended to extend the life of the non-stick coating. Always let the pan cool before washing to avoid warping.

In summary, both types of cookware require specific care and maintenance routines. But with the right care, both can provide years of excellent performance in the kitchen.

Health Implications

In terms of safety, both types of cookware can be safe if used properly. Nonstick pans should not be overheated and should be replaced if the coating starts to chip. Cast iron requires proper care and maintenance to prevent rust and keep the cooking surface safe. Ultimately, both types of cookware can be part of a healthy kitchen, provided they are used and cared for correctly.

Price and Cost

When it comes to price, there’s a noticeable gap between cast iron and nonstick cookware. Typically, high-quality nonstick pans are more affordable upfront, making them a popular choice for those on a tight budget or just starting to equip their kitchen. However, nonstick pans usually have a shorter lifespan, especially if the coating begins to wear or chip, requiring more frequent replacements.

Conversely, cast iron cookware tends to be more expensive initially, reflecting its durability and longevity. High-quality cast iron pans, if cared for properly, can last for decades or even generations, often turning into cherished family heirlooms. Over time, this makes cast iron a cost-effective investment, as the need for replacement is significantly reduced.

In summary, while nonstick cookware may be less expensive initially, the longer lifespan of cast iron pans can make them a more economical choice in the long run. Therefore, when considering price and cost, it’s important to look beyond the upfront price and consider the potential long-term savings.

How to Choose Between Cast Iron or Nonstick

Cooking Style and Needs

The decision between cast iron and nonstick cookware ultimately comes down to your personal cooking style and needs. Nonstick pans are ideal for low and medium heat cooking, perfect for preparing eggs, pancakes, or other delicate foods. They are a go-to for those who prioritize easy cleanup and lightweight handling.

On the contrary, cast iron pans excel in high-heat cooking and are preferred by those who value heat retention and even distribution. They are excellent for searing, roasting, and even baking, offering versatility that extends beyond the stovetop to the oven. Additionally, it is an optimal choice for those who enjoy the process of seasoning and caring for their cookware, and who appreciate pieces that can last a lifetime.

In essence, determine your daily kitchen tasks, the type of meals you frequently prepare, and your cleaning habits. Do you value quick heat-up times, easy-release surfaces, and a lighter weight? Or do you appreciate durable cookware that can withstand high temperatures and improve over time? Answering these questions will guide you to a decision that suits your cooking style and needs the best.

Budget Considerations

Budget is a critical factor when choosing between cast iron and nonstick cookware. Nonstick pans, being more affordable upfront, may initially seem like the more budget-friendly option. They’re especially appealing if you’re setting up a kitchen for the first time or if you’re operating on a tight budget.

However, it’s worth considering the long-term cost implications. Cast iron cookware, while more expensive initially, often proves to be a more cost-effective choice over time due to its remarkable durability. If you’re considering budget from a long-term perspective, investing in a few high-quality cast iron pieces can prove to be economical. You’ll be saving on replacement costs that can accumulate when regularly refreshing a collection of nonstick pans.

So, when considering your budget, think not only about the initial cost. Examine your long-term culinary needs, your cooking habits, and your willingness to take on care and maintenance tasks. An informed decision now can save you money in the long run, while also providing you with a tool that best suits your cooking style.

Longevity and Lifecycle

The lifespan of your cookware is a significant factor to consider, impacting not only the kitchen experience but also the long-term value for money. Nonstick pans, while convenient and easy to maintain, typically have a shorter lifecycle. They require replacement every few years, especially if they are used frequently or the nonstick coating begins to degrade. Overheating and using metal utensils can accelerate this process, resulting in a pan that no longer performs as it should.

Cast iron cookware, on the other hand, boasts an impressive lifespan that can span generations. With proper care, these pans can maintain their quality and performance for decades. Despite their higher upfront cost, their durability makes them a one-time investment that can serve you for a lifetime. Furthermore, seasoned cast iron cookware often improves with age, enhancing its nonstick capabilities over time.

To summarize, while nonstick pans might be a cost-effective choice in the short term, cast iron cookware’s long-lasting nature and potential for improvement with use can make it a more economical choice in the long run. Before making a purchase, consider how frequently you plan to use the cookware and the importance of its durability.

Health and Environmental Factors

When choosing between cast iron and nonstick cookware, health and environmental factors are also vital considerations. Nonstick pans are loved for their ease of use and reduced need for cooking fats, promoting healthier, low-fat cooking. However, concerns have been raised about potential toxins released when nonstick surfaces are overheated. Therefore, they require caution and precise temperature control during cooking.

On the other hand, cast iron cookware is considered a safe and healthy option. Cooking on cast iron can actually add minute amounts of iron to your food, which may be beneficial for those with iron deficiencies. However, it’s important to properly maintain and season cast iron to prevent rust and keep the cooking surface safe and nonstick.

Environmentally speaking, cast iron, with its near-indefinite lifespan, offers sustainability benefits. Its durability means less frequent replacement and consequently less waste. Nonstick pans, while initially more affordable, have a shorter lifespan and may need to be replaced more frequently, contributing to environmental waste. However, advances are being made in producing more eco-friendly nonstick surfaces, so it’s a rapidly evolving field.

In summary, both types of cookware come with their own sets of health and environmental considerations. As a consumer, it’s up to you to weigh these factors according to your personal priorities and make a decision that aligns with your cooking style, health, and environmental consciousness.


What is the primary difference between cast iron and nonstick cookware?

The primary difference lies in their cooking surface: cast iron has a naturally nonstick surface that improves with use and proper seasoning, whereas nonstick cookware has a synthetic coating applied to prevent food from sticking.

Is nonstick or cast iron better for cooking?

This primarily depends on what you’re cooking. Cast iron is excellent for high-heat cooking and searing meats, whereas nonstick pans are better for delicate food like eggs, pancakes, or fish.

How does the durability of cast iron compare to nonstick?

Cast iron pans are incredibly durable and can last for generations if properly cared for, while nonstick pans typically need to be replaced every few years due to wear and tear on the nonstick coating.

Can I use metal utensils with both types of pans?

It is not recommended to use metal utensils with nonstick pans as they can damage the coating. However, cast iron pans can handle metal utensils without issue.

Do cast iron pans heat evenly?

Cast iron pans are known for their superior heat retention, but they do not heat as evenly as nonstick pans. However, once heated, they hold onto that heat quite well.

Is there a taste difference when cooking with cast iron versus nonstick?

Some chefs believe that cast iron adds a distinct flavor to foods, especially when the pan is well-seasoned. Nonstick pans, on the other hand, do not impart any additional flavors to the food.

How do I clean and maintain a cast iron pan?

Cast iron pans should be cleaned with a stiff brush and hot water, then dried thoroughly. It’s also important to season the pan regularly by coating it with a thin layer of oil and heating it.

Can I cook acidic foods in a cast iron pan?

Acidic foods can strip the seasoning off a cast iron pan and potentially react with the metal, leading to a metallic taste. It’s typically recommended to use nonstick or stainless steel for cooking acidic foods.

Are there any weight considerations between cast iron and nonstick?

Cast iron pans are significantly heavier than most nonstick pans. This can be a consideration for those who have trouble lifting heavy items, or for use on certain types of cooktops.


In conclusion, cast iron cooking can be a healthy and beneficial way to cook your meals. It’s a great alternative to other non-stick surfaces with its natural non-stick patina that is formed over time. The biggest surprise of all is that it’s not difficult or laborious to clean—just follow the steps and you should be good! Moreover, it’s versatile, durable, affordable, and excellent for high-heat cooking.

In comparison, non-stick cookware requires more precautions than cast iron when it comes to heat and cleaning solutions. There is no “one size fits all” answer when choosing the right cookware for your kitchen needs; each type has its own advantages and disadvantages.

Whatever type you choose for yourself, I hope this post has equipped you with enough information to make an informed decision. Thank you so much for taking the time in reading this post! If you found this blog helpful please consider sharing your thoughts in the comments section underneath and stay tuned for more interesting reads! For more useful information about cookware and kitchens, visit our website!